Place one graham cracker square in the air fryer basket. Place the marshmallow on the graham cracker. With the other graham cracker square, place the chocolate on top. Set aside.
Cook for 3-4 minutes depending on preferred doneness and the type of air fryer you have (see note about moving marshmallows).
Remove the graham cracker and cooked marshmallow and make a graham cracker sandwich with the other graham cracker and chocolate.
If you want melted chocolate, place the graham cracker with chocolate on it in the air fryer basket for 10-20 seconds. The chocolate will melt quickly!
Method 2
Place the marshmallow in the air fryer basket on its own. Cook for 3-4 minutes until desired doneness.
Roll the cooked marshmallow onto the graham cracker when done.
Notes
There's a lot of moving air in air fryers. When somethings is light, it will be blown around in the air fryer as it cooks. You need to secure the marshmallows down with a toothpick so they cook properly.
Every air fryer cooks differently! We use the foodi smart xl pro by ninja. Make sure to keep an eye on your marshmallows to make sure you cook them to the desired doneness.
Reese's Cups - instead of using chocolate squares, use a Reese's cup as your chocolate base for a peanut butter taste.
Stuffed Marshmallows - replace the regular marshmallow and chocolate square with a chocolate stuffed marshmallows.