This Chocolate Oreo Brownie Trifle recipe is the perfect cookies and cream treat! It's easy to make and so delicious. Packed with Oreos, brownies, cream cheese mousse, and Oreo pudding, this trifle is easy, delicious, and absolutely scrumptious through every single layer.
It's perfect for entertaining: We have made this many times! We like making it for parties, birthdays, events or just a fun night with friends and family. It's beautiful on a holiday dessert table. It's also great because even though it looks amazing, it's so easy to make and is quick to put together too! And chocolate just makes everything better.
Will trifle get soggy overnight? Depending on your layers a trifle doesn't get soggy for 2-3 days. In fact we recommend that a trifle is made in advance so the flavors can blend together nicely. Make at least 1 hour in advance or overnight.
This was inspired by my Oreo Cheesecake Cookies and goes great with our No Bake Oreo Pie, Oreo Blizzard, and our Oreo Fudge. Serve with our fun Tanghulu, and Cookie Dough Dip with Greek Yogurt for a great party spread. Try this fun pudding dessert Dirt Cups.
Ingredients
Below is a list of ingredients needed for this recipe. Follow our tips on each ingredient for best results.
- Oreos- You can use off brand, but just realize it will taste a little bit different.
- Cream cheese- we always recommend Philadelphia cream cheese for maximum smoothness. We have recipe tested with different brands and found that some make the filling a little gritty or even worse, lumpy.
- Oreo/ cookies n cream pudding- You can use Jell-O brand, or an off brand for this one. We suggest using the Jello-o brand, some off brands don't set up as well and may be more liquidy.
- Brownies- We used our favorite box mix, but you can make them homemade for a personal touch!
- Cold milk- Cold is essential for the pudding to set up right! We also recommend using 2% or whole milk for the best results. We tested the pudding with different milk fats and found skim and 1% to be a little more watery and they made the brownies goes soggy faster.
- Dream Whip- This makes the cream cheese mousse so fluffy and wonderful! It can be found near the pudding at your local grocery store.
- Granulated sugar- Basic white granulated sugar for this recipe
- Vanilla- We highly recommend pure vanilla, however imitation will do in a pinch.
How to Assemble Oreo Trifle
Learn how to make brownie trifle with these step by step directions. Begin by making brownies and once cooled, cut into 1" squares. Sometimes I use a box mix; our favorite homemade brownies are the base of these from the Stay at Home Chef.
Then prepare the Oreos by crumbling them into various sizes. Make the Oreo pudding according the package directions.
Last then make the cream cheese mouse by making one package of Dream Whip according to package directions, then mix in the ⅓ cup of sugar. Mix until sugar has dissolved. Place in the fridge. In a second bowl, beat together the softened cream cheese, milk and sugar on high until well blended and smooth and creamy. Fold together the 2 bowls gently, until well combined.
Now you are ready to assemble!
1. Place chopped brownies in the bottom of the trifle bowl.
2. Cover the brownies with ⅓ of the cream cheese mousse filling.
3. Top with a layer of crushed Oreo's.
4. Top with half of the Oreo pudding. Repeat the whole process 2 more times, only the last time you'll end with Oreo's instead of pudding.
Learn From us
One time when I made this, I made it and assembled it the day before. When I went to serve it, it was pretty soggy! The brownies were soggy, the Oreo's were a little soft. It still tasted delicious, but the texture wasn't nearly as good!
All of the individual parts can be made ahead of time by up to a day. The pudding and no bake cheesecake filling both need to be stored in the refrigerator.
Variations
We love switching things up when we're in the kitchen. Try any of these variations for something a little different.
- Peppermint Oreo - use mint Oreo's instead of regular, and add ½ teaspoon peppermint extract to the cream cheese mousse. Perfect for the holidays.
- Strawberry- chop 2 pounds of fresh strawberries and layer them in on top of the Oreos. Check out this Strawberry Trifle recipe for more ideas!
- Heath Toffee Brownie Trifle - buy bite size heath bars and place them on while adding the Oreos, top with a drizzle of caramel on top, if desired.
- Raspberry - Add fresh raspberries. Layer them in on top of the cream cheese mousse and under the Oreos.
Top Tip
To make individual servings, use clear cups or glasses and layer in the trifle elements. This will likely make 12-24 individual cups, depending how large or small they are.
Recipe
Oreo Trifle with Brownies
Equipment
Ingredients
For the brownies:
- 1 9x13 pan of brownies baked and cooled completely. Box mix is fine, or the brownies in this recipe are easy and delicious.
For the Oreo crumbles:
- 1 regular size package Oreos 14.3 oz, crumbled to various sizes.
For the Pudding:
- 2 large boxes Oreo instant pudding mix 4.2 oz each
- Plus 4 cups cold milk to prepare
For the no bake cheesecake filling:
Bowl 1:
- 1 package Dream Whip
- plus ½ cup cold milk and ½ teaspoon vanilla to make according to directions
- ⅓ cup sugar
Bowl 2:
- 8 ounce package cream cheese at room temperature
- 2 Tablespoons milk
- ⅓ cup sugar
Instructions
Brownies:
- Make brownies in 9x13 pan. Cut baked and cooled brownies into 1" squares.
Crumbled Oreos:
- Crumble a regular size package of Oreos. Crumble them into pieces of a variety of sizes.
Oreo Pudding:
- Make the Oreo pudding. Make both boxes together in a bowl according to the directions then place in the fridge.
No Bake Cheesecake Filling:
- In the first bowl, make the Dream Whip according to the package directions, then mix in ⅓ cup sugar.
- In the second bowl (still using an electric mixer) mix together the cream cheese milk and sugar until well blended. Gently fold the cream cheese mixture into the dream whip mixture.
Assembly:
- Start with a layer of brownies at the bottom of the trifle. Line the bottom with brownie pieces.
- Cover with ⅓ of the no bake cheesecake filling, then a layer of crumbled Oreos, and finally ½ the Oreo pudding.
- Repeat. See photos above for a great visual.
- The last (third) time through won't have a layer of Oreo pudding, but will end with Oreo crumbles on top.
Video
Notes
- This doesn't store very well, so try to eat it in the first sitting. Try to make it as close to the time of serving as possible, but it can be made up to 3-4 hours in advance (then refrigerated).
- The different layers can all be made and stored separately up to one day in advance. The pudding and cheesecake filling need to be stored in the refrigerator.
- OREO pudding- while we do recommend Jell-O brand because we have had issues with off brand puddings setting up correctly, you can use off brand cookies and cream pudding in a pinch.
- This is fun to make in individual cups! Use clear plastic cups or glasses and layer in the layers as directed above. It'll make about 12-24 individual trifles depending on cup size.
Mari says
No, there's nothing better than an Oreo dessert haha! And this trifle proves it 😀 I love the brownies and cream cheese and oreo pudding. It was just divine.
JCW says
MMMMM This was really really good. Took it to a party and everyone loved it. I used box brownies. I appreciate that it used up all the ingredients equally without a bunch of leftovers.
Jessica Formicola says
We made this dessert for Thanksgiving and it was a total hit with the whole family! The layers are just divine!
Dana Sandonato says
Such a great idea for a trifle! We're huge fans of Orea-themed desserts in this house so this was a total hit 🙂
Zach says
Easy to make and SUPER pretty = perfect for a party. It doesn't hurt that it's also delicious.
Gina says
Definitely can't go wrong with an Oreo dessert and trifles are always so fun! We loved the brownies, Oreo pudding and cream cheese filling. Easy to assemble and always a crowd pleaser!
Nicole says
It was really easy to make this Oreo Brownie Trifle. And the best part was it was so. dang. good. Chocolatey and delicious. I made it for my friend's birthday and she loved it, and everyone kept asking me for the recipe!
Erin says
Made this for a cookout and it was a hit! So delicious
Carrie Robinson says
So perfect for an Oreo and brownie lover like me! IT was such a yummy trifle! And I just love how easy this is to make too. 🙂
Janae says
This looks so good! I'm hoping to give it a try for Valentine's day. Last time I made a trifle, I left it out on the counter and my dog tipped it over, leaving a big mess on my carpet 🥲 Now that the stain is gone (had to get a carpet cleaner involved) I'm ready to try again!! Thanks for the recipe. ❤️
Leah Micke says
Can you use Cool Whip instead of Dream whip?
Nicole says
Absolutely!
Leah Phillips says
This recipe was a hit when I made it for a gathering! I used cool whip instead of “Dream Whip” and it was great!
Andrea says
So great to here! I'm glad you loved it!
A says
I’m making this for thanksgiving dessert tomorrow. I have all my parts made, just have to assemble tomorrow! I’m excited to try it😋
A says
Update: it was delicious!
Nicole says
Yay!! I'm so glad you loved it! This is one of our all-time favorites.